Yankees Mailbag: Group philosophy, Miguel Andújar and the Rule 5 Draft
Good morning everybody, let’s preserve going with some extra offseason mailbag questions. Keep in mind to ship in your questions for our weekly name by e-mail to pinstripealleyblog [at] gmail [dot] com.
For what it’s price, I don’t assume anybody concerned on the sector is happy with the outcomes that the Yankees have give you. I don’t even assume the entrance workplace feels that approach, both. You might have hit on a strong level although, which is that the Yankees haven’t been a workforce seeking to go all-in but, and perhaps we should always dissect why that’s the case.
Hal Steinbrenner has laid the inspiration for a distinct organizational philosophy than the one which dominated throughout his father’s years. The Yankees’ aim is after all to win the World Collection yearly, however they don’t seem to be prepared to push of their chips every year seeking that aim. Quite, they’ve developed a sustained method constructed round ensuring they’re within the playoffs each season and trusting within the randomness of the postseason.
We’ve talked at size about this subject earlier than, and it has its deserves and its faults. What’s plain, nevertheless, is that it’s an identical mannequin to the one which the Dodgers have constructed for themselves out West. There are some key variations to notice, after all — the Dodgers have managed to win the division outright every of the final eight seasons, have made it to the Fall Basic three out of the final 4 years, and most significantly, got here away with the crown this yr.
Its not a coincidence that the years that the Dodgers began to make important trades — dealing for the likes of Manny Machado, Yu Darvish and Mookie Betts — had been the years that they started making it to the World Collection. The total image right here, nevertheless, is that the Dodgers haven’t gone all-in to make these kinds of trades. They’ve been in a position to ship out prime prospects and nonetheless personal a top-three farm system, one thing the Yankees haven’t come near rivalling after graduating their core of Aaron Judge, Gary Sanchez, Gleyber Torres and Luis Severino. Till the Yankees’ system can go toe-to-toe with the likes of the Dodgers, both from their enchancment or from Los Angeles’ deterioration, they’ll discover themselves a step behind following this technique.
Mikey asks: Miguel Andújar presently is blocked at 3B, LF and DH. Within the occasion that the Yankees commerce Luke Voit for pitching and there’s a gap at 1B, do you assume that Miggy will be groomed to be a defensively satisfactory first baseman?
I believe there’s room to acknowledge two issues which might be concurrently true relating to this query. Andújar’s probably highway to a beginning spot that isn’t at DH is enjoying first base, because it’s the one spot the place you’ll be able to cover his horrible protection. Third base merely isn’t going to chop it for him, and though he acquired a really small pattern dimension within the outfield, I don’t foresee that understanding for him both. First base is historically a spot the place you’ll be able to stow away dangerous protection behind good to nice hitting, although Andújar goes to should work onerous to showcase that his bat can return to the promise it confirmed in his rookie yr.
It additionally is not sensible for the Yankees to be the workforce making an attempt him on the market. If Voit is getting moved, whether or not or not it’s for pitching or another space of want, that transfer needs to be predicated on DJ LeMahieu re-signing with the workforce and taking on at first. Andújar will not be an satisfactory substitute for a down-ballot MVP candidate, nor ought to he be anticipated to be. There actually doesn’t seem to be there’s a job for Andújar in any respect on the workforce, so both he wants to start out in Triple-A to rebuild himself, or he must be given a chance elsewhere.
larry s asks: Are the Yankees at risk of shedding any gamers within the Rule 5 Draft?
The Yankees have a number of gamers eligible for the Rule 5 Draft this yr, they usually received’t have the ability to defend all of them. It’s unsure who the workforce will look to guard by selling them to the 40-man roster simply but, however there’s a pair names who presently might get checked out.
Oswaldo Cabrera, Oswald Peraza, Alexander Vizcaino, Roansy Contreras and Yoendrys Gomez are all gamers that FanGraphs listed within the prime twenty of the group’s prospects, and all are eligible for the Rule 5 Draft. The Yankees presently have 37 gamers on the 40-man roster, together with three gamers who’re on the IL. That doesn’t go away a lot room, if any, for these gamers to get protected, because the workforce has to think about roster spots for gamers presently in free company like LeMahieu.
There’s a good likelihood that every one of those prospects get left unprotected for the Rule 5 Draft, and there’s not a lot the Yankees can do from there. Contemplating that these gamers all misplaced a yr of enjoying actively, nevertheless, groups could also be skittish about selecting up Rule 5 gamers. That would wind up working within the Yankees’ favor as they fight to determine what the futures of those gamers might be.