Throughout the third quarter of 2020, spanning the interval from July by means of September, builders expressed confidence within the metropolis’s long-term financial future, as evidenced by the 446 constructing permits filed throughout the interval, practically matching the 476 filings within the second quarter. Between these functions, which cowl all kinds of initiatives, the brand new residential buildings permitted totaled 5,638 items, a lower from 9,309 the earlier quarter, and a drop from 8,063 items submitted in Q3 of 2019. Regardless of the drop in residential items getting into the pipeline for the 5 Boroughs, total allowing exercise stays comparatively vigorous, and all filings are available in Excel format at the following link.
Total, the share of filings per occupancy sort has modified little from the second quarter. Residential filings proceed to dominate the roster with 70.6 p.c of the general share, down 0.8 p.c from Q2. The remainder of the main classes exhibit single-digit variances. In an unique collection of charts, New York YIMBY tallies the information by particular person standards, portray a nuanced image of the venture that arrived on the drawing boards in Q3 2020.
Variety of filings per proposed occupancy
Residential filings proceed to dominate as successfully as they did within the second quarter. Nonetheless, this time single/two-family residential filings take priority, edging out multi-family filings by seven p.c of the entire, whereas final yr the previous lagged behind the latter by 17 p.c.
Business/mercantile/resort/shelter filings dipped barely by one-and-a-half p.c of the entire share from Q2. On one hand, the dearth of economic filings could also be defined by a continued uncertainty within the workplace market, the place work-from-home association continues to predominate.
Nonetheless, single-quarter filings paint an incomplete image of town’s future workplace market, with hundreds of thousands of economic sq. toes underneath building in skyscrapers corresponding to 50 Hudson Yards, The Spiral, and Two Manhattan West, with many extra megaprojects in planning throughout the boroughs, such because the Empire Station Advanced, Anable Basin, and Innovation QNS, amongst many others. Permits for these developments are anticipated to be filed over the span of many months.
The rely of resort filings has tripled from the final quarter from two to 6, indicating a resurgence in developer confidence within the resort business in one of the tourist-visited cities on the earth.
Flooring space per proposed occupancy
As anticipated, regardless of their decrease whole submitting rely, the entire sq. footage of multi-family residential filings dominate single/two-family filings by greater than an element of ten, since multi-unit condo buildings are inclined to span a lot higher ground areas than their single/two-family counterparts.
The steepest drop within the total share of sq. footage is famous within the industrial/mercantile/resort/shelter class, which fell from 39.8 to 7.9 p.c over the third quarter. Nonetheless, final quarter’ sq. footage rely for the class was inflated by three large Amazon distribution facilities, which added to a mixed 10,442,179 sq. toes, the lion’s share of the quarter’s whole of the 11,923,746 sq. toes for the class. With out these outliers, the remaining quantity is extra constant between Q2 and Q3.
Filings grouped by ground rely
The skyline is town’s boldest manifestation of its artistic prowess, but low-rise buildings have at all times predominated on New York’s cityscape. The third quarter noticed a dramatic enhance in filings for one- to three-story buildings over the second quarter, boosting the share of low-rise (one- to four-story) filings from 70 to 80 p.c of the entire. Mid-rise buildings (5 to 9 tales) account for 16 p.c of the entire, barely beneath final yr’s 22 p.c. Excessive-rise buildings (ten tales and better) comprise the remaining three p.c, 5 p.c factors down from the Q2 determine.
Within the second quarter, three of the tallest proposed buildings have been all residential towers in Brooklyn. This quarter, Manhattan retakes the title of town’s tallest proposal with 777 8th Avenue, a 23-story, 169-room resort proposed in Hell’s Kitchen. The runner-up is an 18-story, 165-unit condo constructing proposed at 26-25 4th Street on the Hallets Level peninsula in Astoria, Queens. Breaking typical expectations, and probably for the primary time within the metropolis’s quarterly submitting historical past, the third-tallest (by ground rely) submitting is a self-storage facility that might rise 17 tales at 155 West 29th Street.
Filings grouped by ground space
The Q3 submitting rely grouped by ground space follows a sample similar to that of Q2, with a predominance of filings spanning underneath 50,000 sq. toes. Within the third quarter, such filings accounted for 94 p.c of the entire, barely surpassing the prior quarter’s 86 p.c tally. As earlier than, essentially the most prolific class spans the 1,000-2,999 square-foot vary, which usually contains single- and two-family filings.
Variety of filings per borough
By way of the general variety of filings per borough, the overall pattern stays comparable between Q2 and Q3, although three boroughs elevated their counts and two noticed their numbers drop. The Bronx elevated its submitting rely by 5 to a complete of 67. Brooklyn’s rely dropped by a whopping 38 filings, right down to 112. Manhattan dropped barely much less precipitously, by 29 filings right down to 10. Submitting counts elevated in each Queens and Staten Island, with the previous gaining six and rising to 145, beating Brooklyn the best rely of any of the boroughs. Staten Island made the best total achieve, with a rise of 26 filings to a complete of 112, tying Brooklyn for second place.
Common ground rely per borough
For essentially the most half, common ground counts have remained secure for allow filings throughout the boroughs. In line with YIMBY’s earlier remark of a rise in low-rise filings within the third quarter, most boroughs have seen slight drops within the averages. The Bronx has seen the best dip, decreasing down by 1.7 flooring to a mean of three.8 flooring. Brooklyn, Manhattan, and Queens have counted extra negligible drops, of 1, 0.6, and 0.2 flooring respectively, right down to the the averages of 4.5, 9.3, and a pair of.9 flooring. Staten Island has remained the identical at 2.4 common flooring.
The constructing with essentially the most flooring proposed in in Manhattan and town generally is 777 8th Avenue (23 flooring, resort). In Queens, the title goes to 26-25 4th Street (18 flooring, residential). Brooklyn’s record-holder is positioned at 2700 Atlantic Avenue (14 flooring residential), in Cypress Hills, far-off from the still-growing skyline in Downtown Brooklyn. The constructing with essentially the most flooring within the Bronx is 2000 Valentine Avenue, with three filings at 11 flooring every. Staten Island’s floor-count champion for Q3 is proposed at 372 St. Mark’s Place, centrally sited in St. George, with two filings every counting 5 flooring.
Complete proposed ground space per borough
In a method, the tally of whole Q3 filings per borough considerably mirrors the rely of whole filings per borough (two charts above). As seen within the aforementioned graph, Manhattan’s whole sq. footage filed in July by means of August path nicely behind that of the Bronx, Brooklyn, and Queens, although the rely between the three is far nearer this time, with Brooklyn barely edging out the Bronx and Queens.
Within the final quarter, Staten Island was the shock chief of the pack, with round twice as a lot whole sq. footage than every other borough. This time, with out the pair of Amazon distribution facilities at 526 Gulf Avenue boosting its whole by practically 10,000,000 sq. toes, the island’s mixed footage for the quarter is “normalized” to final place. Although SI is tied for second place with Brooklyn by way of whole permits, most of the filings signify single- and two-family homes and garages, the 2 typologies with the bottom common sq. footages.
Common ground space per borough
As in prior charts, the elevated prevalence of smaller-scale filings in Q3 explains a lot of the information. Giant-scale proposals proceed to predominate in Manhattan, the place land is sparse and significantly costly whereas the zoning is essentially the most beneficiant of all boroughs. The borough’s common submitting dimension has truly elevated compared to Q2, when it tallied a mean of 80,470 sq. toes.
Common sq. footages per submitting have dropped within the remaining 4 boroughs, most precipitously in Staten Island, the place it fell practically 50 occasions from 124,489 to 2,972 sq. toes. Nonetheless, the borough’s median sq. footages stay comparatively near the earlier rely. With out a number of extraordinary outliers, corresponding to two practically 5,000,000-square-foot Amazon distribution facilities at 526 Gulf Avenue and a 12-story, 274-unit residential constructing deliberate at 475 Bay Street, SI’s common sq. footage is extra reflective of the single- and two-family flings which have dominated each quarters in whole numbers.
Filings by borough and occupancy
With some exceptions, the overall sample of occupancy by borough in Q3 is according to that in Q2. As earlier than, multi-family residential filings dominate within the Bronx and Brooklyn, two of town’s three most densely populated boroughs. The variety of multi-family filings has dropped off drastically in Manhattan, although the remainder of the borough’s submitting varieties stay virtually totally unchanged.
As soon as once more, single- and two-family dwelling proposals predominate in Staten Island, truly growing in Q3 from 58 to 79. The various borough of Queens incorporates massive swathes that resemble something from Brooklyn to Staten Island, and the borough options essentially the most balanced rely of single/two-family versus multi-family filings. In lots of situations, the storage/utility filings account for the garages, therefore their predominance within the extra car-oriented boroughs.
Complete proposed items per borough
Brooklyn, the borough with by far the best variety of multi-family filings in Q3, leads town with essentially the most whole items filed. Although Queens counts virtually half as many multi-family proposals, it practically makes up the hole with a a lot increased variety of single/two-family buildings on the drawing boards, with the Bronx trailing carefully behind.
Manhattan’s 4 residential filings pale compared with Staten Island’s whole of 82, but the previous’s massive scale of deliberate developments nonetheless holds extra items than the predominantly single- and two-family households in planning.
As anticipated in an unsure market, many classes within the third quarter dipped compared to the second quarter. Nonetheless, New York Metropolis has nonetheless posted remarkably sturdy numbers given the present local weather. Moreover, tens of hundreds of thousands of sq. toes are nonetheless deliberate throughout the boroughs, from single-family buildings to megaprojects such because the Empire Station Advanced, Anable Basin, and Innovation QNS, and plenty of others that anticipate permits to be filed over the span of many months.
Given the resilience town’s building and actual property markets have proven even within the hardest of occasions, we anticipate far more growth to floor throughout the 5 boroughs within the close to future.
Subscribe to YIMBY’s day by day e-mail
Native New Yorker. Travel addict. Hardcore thinker. Analyst. Pop culture fanatic. I live in Queens with my wife Linda and our dog Clemenza.