Understanding Staten Island’s District 31 Elementary School Landscape
Staten Island’s District 31 serves as the educational backbone for thousands of elementary students across the borough. As New York City’s most suburban district, District 31 encompasses a diverse collection of elementary schools, each with its unique strengths, programs, and community character. For parents navigating school choice decisions, understanding the complete landscape of rankings and performance data is crucial for making informed decisions about their children’s educational future.
This comprehensive guide breaks down the performance metrics, rankings, and key characteristics of District 31 elementary schools, providing parents with the data-driven insights they need to evaluate their options effectively.
How Staten Island Elementary Schools Are Ranked and Evaluated
Staten Island District 31 elementary schools are evaluated using multiple criteria that provide a holistic view of school performance. Understanding these metrics helps parents interpret rankings more effectively:
Key Performance Indicators
- New York State Test Scores: English Language Arts (ELA) and Mathematics proficiency rates
- School Quality Reports: Comprehensive assessments including student progress and school environment
- Graduation Readiness: Preparation for middle school transition
- Student Growth Metrics: Year-over-year academic improvement
- School Climate Surveys: Parent, student, and teacher satisfaction ratings
- Special Programs: Availability of gifted and talented, dual language, and specialized curricula
Top-Performing Elementary Schools in District 31
Tier 1: Highest-Rated Schools
The highest-performing elementary schools in District 31 consistently demonstrate exceptional academic achievement across multiple metrics. These schools typically feature:
- ELA proficiency rates exceeding 70%
- Mathematics proficiency rates above 75%
- Strong parent and community engagement
- Comprehensive enrichment programs
- Experienced teaching staff with advanced credentials
Schools in this tier often include institutions like PS 29 Bardwell, PS 41 New Dorp, and PS 8 Louis Pasteur, which have established reputations for academic excellence and innovative programming.
Tier 2: Strong Academic Performers
The second tier includes schools with solid academic performance and unique program offerings. These institutions typically maintain:
- ELA proficiency rates between 55-70%
- Mathematics proficiency rates between 60-75%
- Specialized programs such as STEM or arts integration
- Active parent-teacher associations
- Strong community partnerships
Specialized Programs and School Features
Gifted and Talented Programs
Several District 31 elementary schools offer gifted and talented programs designed to challenge high-achieving students. These programs typically feature accelerated curricula, project-based learning, and enrichment activities that extend beyond standard grade-level expectations.
Dual Language and ESL Support
With Staten Island’s diverse population, many District 31 schools provide robust English as a Second Language (ESL) support and dual language programs. These initiatives help multilingual students succeed academically while maintaining their cultural and linguistic heritage.
STEM and Technology Integration
Modern Staten Island elementary schools increasingly emphasize Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM) education. Many schools feature computer labs, robotics programs, and integrated technology curricula that prepare students for 21st-century learning.
Factors Beyond Test Scores: What Parents Should Consider
School Culture and Environment
While test scores provide important data points, the overall school culture significantly impacts student experience and success. Consider factors such as:
- Class sizes and student-teacher ratios
- Disciplinary policies and school climate
- Extracurricular activities and after-school programs
- Communication between school administration and families
- Safety measures and protocols
Special Needs Support
District 31 schools vary in their special education resources and support services. Parents of students with special needs should investigate:
- Availability of specialized staff and resources
- Inclusion practices and support strategies
- Related services such as speech therapy or occupational therapy
- Individualized Education Program (IEP) implementation
Making the Right Choice for Your Child
School Visit Recommendations
Rankings provide valuable baseline information, but visiting schools personally offers irreplaceable insights. During school visits, observe classroom dynamics, interact with staff and administrators, and assess whether the school environment aligns with your child’s learning style and personality.
Considering Transportation and Logistics
Staten Island’s geography means transportation can significantly impact daily routines. Factor in commute times, bus routes, and pickup/drop-off logistics when evaluating school options, especially if considering schools outside your immediate neighborhood zone.
Resources for Ongoing School Research
Stay informed about District 31 elementary school performance through official NYC Department of Education resources, including School Quality Reports, annual test score releases, and district communications. Parent networks and community groups also provide valuable firsthand insights into school experiences and changes.
Choosing the right elementary school for your child involves balancing multiple factors, from academic performance and test scores to school culture and specialized programs. Staten Island’s District 31 offers diverse options, each with unique strengths and characteristics that serve different student needs and family priorities.
While rankings and scores provide important objective data, remember that the best school for your child is one that supports their individual learning style, interests, and developmental needs. Use this comprehensive information as a starting point for deeper research, school visits, and conversations with educators and other parents in the Staten Island community.
By taking a holistic approach to school evaluation and staying engaged with your child’s educational journey, you can make confident decisions that set the foundation for long-term academic success and personal growth.

Born and raised amidst the hustle and bustle of the Big Apple, I’ve witnessed the city’s many exciting phases. When I’m not exploring the city or penning down my thoughts, you can find me sipping on a cup of coffee at my favorite local café, playing chess or planning my next trip. For the last twelve years, I’ve been living in South Williamsburg with my partner Berenike.