Did You Bring Back These Top 5 NYC Souvenirs?

Ah, New York City – the Big Apple, the City That Never Sleeps, and dare we say, the unofficial capital of cool souvenirs. Let’s face it, part of the adventure is coming back with a suitcase that’s a tad heavier, filled with goodies that scream “Hey, I’ve been to NYC!”

Now, you might be wondering what treasures to bring back from your urban expedition. Fret not! We’re about to dive into the crème de la crème of NYC souvenirs.

From iconic tees to java that jolts you awake faster than a New York minute, these are the best souvenirs from NYC to keep the city’s heartbeat close no matter where you roam.

Ready to reminisce on subway rides and skyline views with every sip and sight? Buckle up! We’re hitting the streets to uncover the top 5 must-have NYC souvenirs that deserve a special place in your home (and heart).

1. “I Love NY” T-shirt

Picture this: you’re strolling down the bustling streets of New York City, the sights and sounds buzzing around you like electricity. Suddenly, amidst the whirl of yellow cabs and towering skyscrapers, a familiar emblem catches your eye—the bold “I ♥ NY” splashed across a classic white tee. It’s the iconic NYC souvenir that’s shouting, “Take a piece of the Big Apple home with you!”

The Tale Behind the Tee

Let’s rewind to the 1970s, a time when New York City’s sparkle had dimmed under economic woes and high crime rates. Enter graphic designer Milton Glaser, who doodled the now-famous logo on a scrap of paper in a taxi ride—a design that would become synonymous with New York’s resilience. The “I Love NY” T-shirt wasn’t just fabric and ink; it was an emblem of hope, a badge of pride for locals and visitors alike.

Hunt for Authenticity

Now, where can one snag an authentic “I Love NY” T-shirt? For starters:

  • Grand Slam New York: A treasure trove located in Times Square, offering everything from classic tees to rare finds.
  • Official NYC Information Centers: Drop by for tourist info and walk out with the real deal in official merchandise.

When hunting for that perfect tee, keep an eye out for these clues:

  • Official Licensing Tags: Like finding Willy Wonka’s golden ticket but for genuine NYC gear.
  • Quality Check: A quick inspection goes a long way—after all, you want it to survive more than one wash cycle!
  • Design Diversity: Go beyond the classic red heart—New York is a melting pot of creativity!

Tips for Tee Perfection

Before you exchange your dollars for that wearable memento, let’s talk strategy:

  • Feel the Fabric: Softness matters; who wants to rock a cardboard-esque shirt?
  • Size it Right: Baggy or fitted? Channel your inner New Yorker and choose what makes you strut with confidence.
  • Snap Up Unique Variations: From rainbow hearts during Pride to artsy renditions in boutique shops, why not stand out?

Snagging an “I Love NY” T-shirt is like capturing lightning in a bottle—it’s electric, it’s iconic, and it’s undeniably New York. Whether folded neatly in your drawer or worn on your next adventure, this piece isn’t just about style—it’s about stories. So next time someone asks about your NYC trip as they point to your chest, you’ll have more than just fabric to share—you’ll have your very own New York moment.

2. Statue of Liberty Memorabilia

Statue of Liberty memorabilia, Statue of Liberty replicas, Statue of Liberty gift shops…these phrases might have popped up in your search engine while preparing for your trip to the Big Apple.

A trip to New York City is incomplete without a visit to the iconic statue. Representing freedom and democracy, Lady Liberty has been welcoming immigrants and visitors since 1886. This emblematic figure has sparked an entire industry dedicated to Statue of Liberty memorabilia, making it a popular keepsake among tourists from all over the globe.

Why Statue of Liberty Memorabilia?

Imagine walking down the streets of your hometown with a keychain swinging on your bag or keys showcasing a miniature version of the Statue of Liberty. Pretty cool, right? But there’s more! Walk into any souvenir shop in NYC and you’ll be greeted by a plethora of options.

  1. Replicas: Ranging from pocket-sized to larger versions, these are perfect for decorating your home or office desk.
  2. Keychains: A practical souvenir that will remind you daily of your NYC adventure.
  3. Postcards: Classic collectibles that capture scenic views of Lady Liberty herself.

Where to Find the Best Statue of Liberty Souvenirs?

Now that we’ve stirred up some excitement, let’s move onto where you can hunt for these treasures. If you’re looking for authenticity, make sure to visit the specialty gift shops near Battery Park or Ellis Island. These spots offer a wide variety of Statue of Liberty memorabilia that cater to different tastes and budgets.

How to Choose the Perfect Souvenirs?

Here’s where things get interesting though: How do you choose the best souvenirs?

  1. Reflect on what the statue represents to you: Is it her torch representing enlightenment? Or perhaps the seven spikes on her crown signifying the seven seas and continents? Choose souvenirs that mirror these features for a more personal touch.
  2. Artistic representations: Look out for creative interpretations such as those featuring pop art or abstract designs. These make for unique conversation starters back home.

With this in mind, we hope you’re now ready to embark on your Statue of Liberty souvenir mission. Just remember, the best mementos are those that help you relive the experience and share your tales of exploring the city that never sleeps.

3. New York Roasted Coffee

New York City is buzzing, and it’s not just because of the city’s dynamic energy. Nope, it’s the caffeine! The city that never sleeps thrives on coffee, with its love for the brew influencing a rich coffee culture and a fine craft of roasting beans. Locally-roasted coffee beans have become an integral part of New York’s identity, making it one of the most popular souvenirs to take back home from NYC.

So, let’s spill the beans about some of this city’s top coffee roasters, shall we?

A Sip into the Coffee Culture

New York City isn’t just about skyscrapers and bright lights; it is also a melting pot of diverse cultures. This diversity reflects in the city’s coffee scene too, with myriad roasters adding their unique twists to the traditional art of coffee roasting.

Two names that stand out in the crowd are Blue Bottle Coffee and Irving Farm. Both these local favorites have their roasting facilities right in the heart of New York City, ensuring that every cup you pour carries a strong whiff of the Big Apple!

Where to Bag These Beans

Finding your perfect New York roasted coffee souvenir is an adventure in itself. Specialty cafes and markets are your treasure troves for these aromatic delights.

One such place is Chelsea Market, where you can find a variety of locally roasted coffee beans displayed like precious jewels. Another gem is Greenpoint Terminal Market, known for its array of artisanal products including premium quality coffee.

Choosing Your Perfect Blend

Choosing from a sea of coffee options can be overwhelming! Here are some tips to help you navigate:

  • Look for coffee blends inspired by iconic neighborhoods or landmarks. Just like NYC, each blend has its own character: bold, subtle, sweet or strong.
  • Check out the roasting date on the bag. The fresher the roast, the better the flavor.
  • If you’re a fan of a specific type of coffee (e.g., espresso or cold brew), ensure that the blend you’re buying is suitable for that.

Remember, each coffee souvenir from NYC is not just a bag of beans; it’s an experience, a taste of the city’s vibrant energy and diverse culture. So next time you’re in New York City, don’t forget to pack some of this caffeinated gold in your suitcase! But hey, no rush. We still have more NYC treasures to uncover!

4. Broadway Show Merchandise

Picture the bright lights of Times Square, the buzz of the crowd at intermission, and that electrifying moment when the curtain rises. Broadway shows are not just performances; they’re experiences that stick with you long after the final bow. And what better way to keep a piece of that magic than with some authentic Broadway show merchandise?

Lights, Camera, Memorabilia! Theater lovers know, a trip to NYC is incomplete without catching a Broadway hit. Whether you’re humming along to Hamilton or getting swept away by The Phantom of the Opera, these shows leave you wanting a tangible memory. Cue the merch!

  • Iconic Souvenirs from Iconic Shows: Think tees emblazoned with your favorite show’s logo, glossy programs filled with production photos, or mugs that make every coffee break a dramatic interlude.
  • Character Love: Are you team Alexander Hamilton or Christine Daaé? Pick up character-themed goodies—from Aaron Burr keychains to masquerade masks reminiscent of the Opera Ghost.

Where Dreams Are Made Of Times Square isn’t just for photo ops; it’s also where you’ll find a treasure trove of theater souvenirs in NYC.

  • The Hamilton Store: A haven for fans of the revolutionary musical. From ‘The Room Where It Happens’ notebooks to ‘Young, Scrappy, and Hungry’ wristbands.
  • The Theatre Shop: Your one-stop shop for all things Broadway. Whether it’s a Wicked-inspired witch hat or an Avenue Q puppet, they’ve got your back.

Choosing Your Encore Selecting merchandise that resonates with your Broadway experience makes all the difference.

  • Go for Significance: Did a particular scene or song strike a chord? Find merchandise that captures that moment—like a poster featuring the iconic skyline from In The Heights.
  • Quality Over Quantity: Opt for well-made items that’ll stand the test of time (and repeated use). A sturdy tote bag sporting the Les Misérables emblem, perhaps?

Whether you’re gifting yourself or a fellow theater enthusiast, these keepsakes serve as daily reminders of those show-stopping New York nights. And remember, while sipping coffee from a cup adorned with playbill snippets or wearing your Dear Evan Hansen hoodie, each item tells a story—a story where you played a part in the audience of the world’s greatest stage.

5. Brooklyn-made Artisanal Goods

Did you know? Brooklyn is not only known for its iconic bridge and hipster vibe, but it’s also a treasure trove of creativity and craftsmanship. A stroll through this borough will reveal a vibrant community of artisans, each putting their unique spin on the city’s culture through their handcrafted goods.

Discover Unique Stores in Brooklyn

Artists & Fleas

Artists & Fleas is a must-visit for art enthusiasts and craft lovers alike, offering a diverse range of items from local artists, designers, and vintage vendors. Whether you’re hunting for handmade jewelry, original artworks or even vintage vinyl records, this market offers an array of authentic Brooklyn vibes.


On the other hand, Catbird has won the hearts of locals and tourists alike with its delicate jewelry pieces – all made at their Brooklyn studio. Their tiny charms and dainty rings serve as beautiful mementos of your NYC trip.

More Places to Explore

But wait! The borough has more to offer in terms of artisanal goods. You might want to check out:

  1. The popular Williamsburg Flea Market – where you can find all things vintage – clothes, furniture, records – alongside locally made crafts.
  2. The Brooklyn Makers Market at Industry City – a celebration of local makers where you can find handcrafted souvenirs that truly represent the borough’s creative essence.

Choose Sustainable Souvenirs

Now let’s talk about being responsible tourists! By choosing eco-friendly or upcycled items as your souvenirs, you’re not just bringing home something unique – you’re also supporting sustainable tourism. Many Brooklyn artisans focus on creating products that are not only beautiful but also kind to the planet. So why not choose a souvenir that tells a story of sustainability?

From hand-poured soy candles to upcycled clothing, these items serve as a reminder of Brooklyn’s commitment to a greener future. So next time you’re in the borough, make sure to keep an eye out for these eco-friendly gems!

So, Brooklyn-made artisanal goods – check! But hold on, there’s more in store for you! Are you ready?


Snagging the best souvenirs from NYC isn’t just about bringing home goodies; it’s about capturing the heart and soul of your Big Apple adventure. Each trinket, from an I Love NY tee to a Brooklyn artisanal creation, holds a piece of the city’s vibrant energy.

Here are some final tips to make the most out of your NYC souvenir hunt:

  1. Cherish Your Memories: Let your mementos be daily reminders of the city’s bustling streets, towering skyscrapers, and unforgettable experiences. Whether displayed on a shelf or worn with pride, each item tells a story of your journey.
  2. Explore & Discover: Venture beyond the well-trodden paths of Midtown Manhattan. Each neighborhood, from the bohemian vibes of Greenwich Village to the historic streets of Harlem, offers unique treasures waiting to become part of your collection.
  3. Get Creative at Home: Why not use that NYC skyline snow globe as a paperweight that draws your gaze during long workdays? Or transform Broadway playbills into a stunning wall collage? Get inventive and integrate New York’s flair into your everyday life.
  4. Share Your Stories: Jump onto social media with #MyNYCSouvenir and join a community sharing their finds. Relive the thrills of Times Square or the serenity of Central Park through fellow travelers’ eyes.

Remember, NYC souvenirs are more than mere objects; they’re tangible memories that keep the city’s magic pulsing through your veins until you return… Because let’s face it, one trip is never enough! 🗽✨